Keto milk pie or Greek Galatopita

Keto milk pie, or as the Greeks call it Galatopita, is one of the creamiest and dreamiest desserts for the fast approaching holidays. Naturally, we don’t consume milk on Keto, so how can we make this ketonisation successful? Greek custard pie known as Galatopita can sound tricky, but we’ll make it as simple as possible! Don’t you worry about the carbs and starch because the well-experienced ketonisation team works on it! 😉

If you never heard about Galatopita, it’s one of the most loved Greek desserts. Some call it a pudding pie! Interestingly, pudding in Greece is not a typical dessert, but when baked as creamy milk pie, things get steamy and passionate! Everybody loves Galatopita! Originally, it’s made with milk, semolina, eggs and – what else – sugar. Unfortunately, most traditional Greek desserts use these ingredients. However, we are Ketonians, aren’t we? We know how to replace the bad and ugly ingredients!

Keto milk pie with zero starch

Avoiding starch, cereal-flours and sugar makes Keto desserts healthy. So, this will not be a difficult ketonisation. What makes this Keto milk pie so irresistible is the caramelisation that occurs during the baking process. How shall we imitate this without added sugar? Well, natural occurring sugars, as low as they are, will still get caramelised during the baking process.

What means Galatopita?

As you might already know, (γᾰ́λᾰ – gála) is a Greek word for milk. Pita, on the other side, can be a pie, but can also be a cake! In fact, you might remind you of the word galactose (naturally occurring sugar in food). Furthermore, you can connect this word to the galaxy! Yes, ancient Greeks gave this name to the modern astronomic term, and it has been used in literature, art and poetry for ages! The connection is quite simple! You know that we are located in the Milky way galaxy! Well, for Ancient Greeks γαλαξίας (galaxías, “Milky Way”), came from γάλα (gála, “milk”). There’s a myth about goddess Hera and milking baby Hercules which you can read here.

Keto milk pie
Photo from www.wikipedia.com The Milky Way arching at a high inclination across the night sky. (This composited panorama was taken at Paranal Observatory in northern Chile). The bright object is Jupiter in the constellation Sagittarius, and the Magellanic Clouds can be seen on the left. Galactic north is downward.

Is it a pudding or is it a custard?

The history of the pudding is a complex subject. How can something that simple be complicated? Though the history, numerous different kinds of foods have been called pudding. The smooth and creamy pudding dessert we know today is actually a custard. And the history of custard is also complicated and quite ancient. The custard was mixed up with pudding sometimes in the 19 century, which is quite new.

Food historians usually agree that the proto-pudding was prepared by ancient cooks and it looked like a sausage. The British consider it as their national culinary heritage. But this version draws a connection to Medieval puddings, in most cases, made with meat. In the 17th century, savoury English puddings were always meat-based. If a sweet version was prepared it would include flour, nuts and sugar. Somehow, in the second part of the 18th century, traditional English pudding stopped including meat. With the arrival of 19th-century, puddings were still boiled but the final result was more like a cake.

Keto milk pie

Ancient Greek and Roman love of eggs

Ancient Greek and Roman cooks realised the binding characteristics of eggs. In fact, they mastered the design of various egg-based dishes. Omelettes, patinae, and puddings were prepared in noble Roman homes. Today we know, eggs are really versatile and they also have great thickening power! Galatopita is an excellent example of that! However, our Keto milk pie will bring it all to a healthier level.

Unfortunately, sometime in the 1840s, Alfred Bird, an English food manufacturer and chemist, introduced custard powder as an alternative to egg thickeners. Guess what, it was? He used pure corn starch!

From that moment onwards, puddings started creating bloating and gastrointestinal problems to sensitive people. Interestingly, the original non-starch pudding was always an easy going food! Nevertheless, we will ditch the starch and flours and go back to eggs! After all, eggs are one of most nutritious foods on earth! They are almost a staple of Keto Mediterranean diet!

Ready to make the ultimate ketonisation of Greek Keto milk pie?

Keto milk pie / Galatopita

0 from 0 votes
Recipe by Roberta Kapsalis Course: Keto dessertCuisine: Keto MediterraneanDifficulty: Medium


Prep time


Cooking time






  • 500g (17,6 oz) mascarpone or goat cream cheese

  • 150 ml (5 fl oz) fresh, organic goat milk (full fat) or just use water

  • 4 large eggs (pasture raised)

  • 1 tbsp powdered grass-fed beef gelatine

  • 4 micro-scoops of powdered monk fruit or stevia extract (or 8 drops liquid extract)

  • 1/3 tsp sea salt

  • 1 tsp vanilla extract

  • 1 pinch nutmeg

  • Crust (optional)
  • 8 tbsp ground macadamia or blanched hazelnuts

  • 2 tbsp coconut flour

  • 5 tbsp melted butter (preferably sheep, goat or buffalo butter)

  • 1 tbsp lemon zest

  • 1 micro scoop stevia or monk fruit powdered extract or 4 drops of liquid one

  • 1/4 tsp sea salt


  • If you decide to make the Keto milk pie with a crust, prepare it first. Mix all the dry ingredients and then add melted butter. Grease a 22 cm (9′) pie pan with some butter or coconut oil and place the crust mixture in it. Tap it with your fingers to flatten. Bake for 10 minutes at 180ºC (356ºF) After that, you will pour in the pudding and bake it further as described below.
  • If you decide to bake the Galatopita without a crust, butter up the pan and sprinkle with some coconut flour to prevent sticking.
  • For the filling, place the mascarpone and goat milk into a deep saucepan, mix well and heat it over medium temperature.
  • Beat the eggs with vanilla extract, cinnamon, salt, nutmeg and stevia using an electric mixer. Add powdered gelatine and keep mixing.
  • When the milk and mascarpone mixture boils, remove it from the heat. Gently pour in the egg mixture and stir energetically with a whisk.
  • Return the pudding on the stove and cook for 4 minutes. Constantly stir! Then let it cool down for a couple of minutes.
  • Pour in the pudding on the half-baked crust (or in case you don’t want to use the crust, pour it in the pan that you greased with butter and sprinkled with coconut flour)
  • Bake for 20 minutes at 170ºC (338ºF). When the pie is baked, remove it from the oven and let it cool down. You can decorate it with some cinnamon, powdered stevia blend sweetener or slices of lemon/lime. 
  • Refrigerate for at least 4 hours before serving.


  • 100 ml of organic goat milk contains 3,4g of naturally occurring sugar. If you would like to reduce this, you can just use plain water.
  • It would be wise to avoid sweeteners blends with erythritol, but if this is the only one you have, use 2 tablespoons in the pudding and 1 tablespoon in the crust.
  • The nutritional labels shown bellow are calculated separately so that you can decide if you will use the crust or not. Also, look at the difference in carb content if you decide to use water instead of goat milk. It’s up to you! You can make this creation a low-carb one or a real Keto dessert! 😉

Did you make this recipe?

Tag @greekgoesketo on Instagram and hashtag it with #greekgoesketo

Similar Posts


    1. Hello Jessa, thank you very much for your positive comment. Please have a look, we have over 200 recipes and various articles here on the website. Also, please check out our YouTube channel as well 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *